22 Greenmanville Ave.
Mystic, CT 06355


Consignments Accepted Monday-Friday 9:30-4:00 




We can now also be found on Instagram!

Now Accepting


Boyfriend, Skinny and Straight Leg Jeans and Pants
Designer Denim
TOMS Shoes
Sperry Top-Siders
Ankle-strap Pointy Toe Flats
Popover Shirts 
Boyfriend Shirts 
Chambray Shirts
Pencil Skirts
Athleisure Wear
Cross-Body Bags
Bright Totes
Statement Jewelry
Jewelry- Sterling, Gold, Vintage
Designer Purses

Not Accepting
Department Store Brands, Knock-offs or Imitations, Items More Than Two Seasons Old, Winter Items

Best Selling Brands

Abercrombie & Fitch, Alex & Ani, American Eagle, Ann Taylor, Banana Republic, BCBG, Boden, Born, Burberry, Calvin Klein, Coach, Cole Haan, Columbia, Converse, Dansko, David Meister, Diane Von Furstenberg, DKNY, Dolce & Gabanna, Dooney & Bourke, Eileen Fisher, Ella Moss, Elie Tahari, Express, Fendi, Fossil, Free People, Frye, Gap, Gucci, H&M, Hollister, Jack Rogers, J.Crew, Jimmy Choo, Judith Ripka, Juicy Couture, Kate Spade, Lacoste, Laundry by Shelli Segal, Lenny & Eva, Lilly Pulitzer, Longchamp, Lucky Brand, Lululemon, Madewell, Marc Jacobs, Marmot, Michael Kors, Minnetonka, Nanette Lepore, Patagonia, Polo, Prada, Puma, Ralph Lauren, Roxy, Sperry Top-Sider, Stella and Dot, Stuart Weitzman, The Limited, The North Face, Theory, Tibi, Tiffany & Co, Trina Turk, TOMS Shoes, Tory Burch, Ugg, Valentino, Vineyard Vines

Premium Denim: 
AG Jeans, Citizens of Humanity, Current/Elliott, Diesel, Hudson, J Brand, Joeʼs Jeans, Lucky Brand, Miss Sixty, Paige Premium, 7 For All Mankind, True Religion

Contact Us!

 While what we really enjoy is seeing your smiling faces in person, you may also feel free to call or email us with any questions you may have regarding your account, balance, which items we are currently accepting or anything else you may be curious about! You can also find answers to your questions in the How to Consign/FAQs section of our website. We are available everyday from 9:30am to 5:00pm (Sundays 11:00am to 5:00pm).  We look forward to hearing from you!

Steve Madden

Steve Madden is more than just the store pet, he plays an active role in the daily operations at Pennywise. He's always sharing his fashion advice and is getting better at looking up customer's balances (aka sprawling out across the Pennywise laptops). Visit Steve's Corner often to keep track of Steve's most recent fashion picks and visting friends.

The Latest from the Ladies at Pennywise


Now Accepting Spring Consignments!

The weather may not feel like it but Spring is right around the corner and we want to be ready for it! We are now accepting Spring consignments (not yet Summer). This year our customers are looking for skinny and boyfriend fit jeans and pants, chambray and boyfriend shirts, shirtdresses, Sperry Top-Siders and TOMS and brightly colored bags. As always, we do not accept department store brands. Our best selling brands are J.Crew, Banana Republic, Lilly Pulitzer, Vineyard Vines and high-end designer labels such as Diane Von Furstenberg, Theory, Prada and Tory Burch. For a complete list of the brands we accept and what we are currently looking for please refer to the lists on the right hand menu of this page. For a complete list of our rules and regulations please check out the How to Consign/FAQs section of our website. See you soon!


Accepting Spring January 26

Our new system is up and running so we are ready to start thinking Spring! On Monday, January 26 we begin accepting select early spring items (no summer yet). We are looking for skinny, straight and boyfriend fit jeans, popover shirts, boyfriend fit shirts, shirtdresses, TOMS and Sperry Top-Siders, athleisure wear, brightly colored accessories and high-end designer items. As always, we do not accept department store brands and do not accept consignments on weekends. For more information on our consignment process please check out the How to Consign/FAQs section of this site. You can find a list of acceptable brands in this section or on the right hand toolbar. See you soon!


No Longer Accepting Winter Items, Except for...

We are no longer accepting Winter items with the exception of UGG and Frye boots, The North Face and Patagonia Jackets and high-end designer items. We can still accept jewelry, wallets and purses. For more information on our consignment process please click on the FAQS/How to Consign link at the top of this page. Please keep up with us here and on Facebook and Twitter for more information and updates.  

For all of you shoppers, follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter (all @PennywiseMystic) for daily pics of inventory and sales. We are fully stocked withCole Haan Purse great gifts for everyone including designer accessories, jewelry and gift cards for those hard to shop for people on your list! We are open seven days a week. Happy holidays! 


November Update

Madewell coat, Stella & Dot purse, Joes Jeans and DVF bootiesNovember is here and it finally feels like fall! We are currently accepting winter items such as Frye and UGG boots, North Face jackets, J.Crew, Madewell and Banana Republic sweaters and coats and high-end designer items. For a complete list of what we are looking for as well as the brands we accept please refer to the list on the right hand side of this page. For more info on our consignment process check out the How to Consign/FAQs section of this site. We are accepting winter consignments until Tuesday, November 25 this year. We will not be accepting consignments or issuing checks on Veterans Day. 
Now is also the time of year to think about holiday gifts. We have a huge selectionAlex and Ani Bracelets of jewelry including Alex and Ani and Tiffany and designer purses from Coach, Kate Spade and Michael Kors to name a few. Gift cards are also available for any amount and they never expire! Visit us seven days a week and we will help you find the perfect gift. 


Currently Accepting for October

We are currently accepting women's and men's winter items at Pennywise on Greenmanville Ave. As always, we only accept name brands and designer items (no department store brands). For a full list of the brands we accept and what we are currently looking for please refer to the list at on the right hand side of this page. We already have wait lists for Frye boots and North Face fleeces and jackets. In addition to this our customers are looking for plaid flannels, boyfriend fit jeans, crossbody bags and Sperry's and TOMS. For more information on our consignment process please click on the How to Consign/FAQS page of this website. Please keep in mind we have thousands of active consignors and sometimes run out of room for more consignments so it is always a good idea to call and check before making the trip. We are always able to take in more earlier in the week as we clear out over the weekend.