Two Locations!

22 Greenmanville Ave.
Mystic, CT 06355


Consignments Accepted Monday-Friday 9:30-4:00 

25 Cottrell St.
Mystic, CT 06355


Consignments Accepted Monday-Friday 10:00-4:00 

We can now also be found on Pinterest and Instagram!

Now Accepting


Boyfriend and Straight Leg Jeans and Pants
Designer Denim
Colorful and Pattern Skinnies
TOMS Shoes
Sperry Top-Siders
Ankle-strap Pointy Toe Flats
Popover Shirts 
Boyfriend Shirts 
North Face and Patagonia Fleeces and Lightweight Jackets
Chambray Shirts
Boxy Top Jackets
Cargo Jackets
Longer Length Sweaters
Pencil Skirts
Schoolboy Style Blazers
Cross-Body Bags
Bright Totes
Statement Jewelry
Jewelry- Sterling, Gold, Vintage
Designer Purses
Colorful Rain Boots
Vintage Clothing and Accessories

Not Accepting Department Store Brands, Summer Items, Knock-offs or Imitations, Flared Jeans and Pants, Items More Than Two Seasons Old


The Latest from the Ladies at Pennywise


Now Accepting Lightweight Fall for Back to School!

We know summer is still here but we have to start getting ready for back to school shopping! We are now accepting lightweight fall clothing (adult's at Pennywise and children's at Pennywise Downtown). We are not yet accepting heavy sweaters, coats or cords. This year everyone's asking for TOMS and Sperry Top-Siders along with chambray shirts, shirtdresses, and skinny, straight or boyfriend fit jeans and pants. As always we do not accept department store brands. For a complete list of what we are currently looking for and the brands we are looking for refer to the lists at the right of this page. To find out more about our consignment process please click on the How to Consign link at the top of this page.

Summer isn't over quite yet so don't forget to check out the 50% off summer clearance at both locations! We are clearing out the tank tops, shorts, capris and sundresses to make room. All of your favorite brands including J.Crew, Madewell, Ann Taylor, Free People and Gap are included! Now thru August 31 spend $50 at one location and get a receipt for 50% off one full price item at the other location when you shop the same day! Both stores are open seven days a week. See you soon!


Summer Clearance!

It's time to clear out our summer stock and make room for fall which means a huge sale! Check out both locations for 50% off summer clearance racks. At Pennywise on Greenmanville Ave. you will find women's shorts, tanks, capris and sundresses at huge discounts along with men's summer clothing. At Pennywise Downtown on Cottrell Ave. you will find women's summer clothing plus kid's summer clothing at 50% off of the lowest ticket prices! Don't forget about our 50/50 sale going on until the end of August. When you spend $50 at one location you can get half off one regularly priced item at the other location if you shop the same day. 

We will begin accepting lightweight fall items on Monday, July 21 (no heavy items yet). Please refer to the How to Consign section of our website for more info and check out the currently accepting lists on the right-hand side of this page. Hope you are all having a wonderful summer!


Accepting Consignments July 21

We are no longer accepting Summer consignments for this year. We will begin accepting early Fall consignments for back to school on July 21.  We are currently stocked with awesome designer items for men and women. Check it out seven days a week at both locations and don't forget our Downtown location is open extended hours for the summer. Our 50/50 Sale is still on until the end of the summer. Spend $50 at one location and earn 50% off one full price item at the other location when you shop the same day! As always, keep up with us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram for sales and inventory pics. We hope to see you soon!


Accepting Summer Items Until June 27

Summer is finally here and we are stocked with great stuff for women and men at Pennywise and women, kids and vintage items at Pennywise Downtown! We will continue accepting Summer items until Friday, June 27. This year our best sellers are Lilly Pulitzer, J.Crew shorts and tanks, fitted sundresses, Sperry's, Jack Rogers and high-end designer items. For a complete list of what we are currently looking for and the brands we accept please refer to the list at the lower right-hand side of this page. For more info on how our process works please click on the How to Consign/FAQs tab. 
Summer is the time to shop at both of our locations. If you spend $50 at one location you can get any full price item for half off at the other location when you shop the same day! This is a Summer exclusive sale so take advantage of it soon. Both locations are open seven days a week! 


Memorial Day Updates!

Summer is almost here! To celebrate our downtown location at 25 Cottrell St. Mystic is now on extended hours. They are now open Monday thru Thursday 10-6, Friday and Saturday 10-8 and Sunday 11-5. Consignments are still accepted Monday thru Friday 10-4. Our location on Greenmanville Ave in Mystic is open normal hours through the summer. Both locations will be openfor sales only (no consignments accepted or checks issued) on Memorial Day.

Both locations are celebrating Memorial Day with 25%-50% off storewide sales! Check out our huge selections of women's and men's clothing at Pennywise and women's, men's, children's and vintage clothing at Pennywise Downtown.