22 Greenmanville Ave.
Mystic, CT 06355

Friday 9:30-7:00
Saturday 9:30-7:00
Sunday 11:00am-5:00pm 

Consignments Accepted Monday-Friday 9:30-4:00
Not on weekends or holidays 




Now Accepting

*Jeans- Mid-rise and High-waisted: Skinny, Straight Leg, Boyfriend Fit and Wide Leg 
*Slim Fit Pants
*Chambray and Boyfriend Fit Shirts
*The North Face and
Patagonia Fleeces and Coats
*Oversized Wool Coats
*Shift dresses
*Midi Dresses and Skirts
*A-line mini skirts
*Pencil Skirts
*Chunky Heel boots
*Sperry Top-Siders and TOMS
*Frye boots
*Bucket Bags
*Designer Purses
*Sterling, Gold and Vintage Jewelry
*Alex & Ani, J.Crew, and Stella & Dot Jewelry

 We Are NOT Accepting
Department store brands, Items more than two seasons old, Knockoffs and Imitations, Formal wear, Suits

Steve Madden

Steve Madden is more than just the store pet, he plays an active role in the daily operations at Pennywise. He's always sharing his fashion advice and is getting better at looking up customer's balances (aka sprawling out across the Pennywise laptops). Visit Steve's Corner often to keep track of Steve's most recent fashion picks and visting friends.

Best Selling Brands and Designers

Abercrombie & Fitch, Adrienne Vittadini, Alex & Ani, Alice + Olivia, American Eagle, Angie, Ann Taylor, Athleta, Banana Republic, BCBG, Coach, Brooks Brothers, Burberry, C&C California, Calvin Klein, Calypso, Chanel, Christian Dior, Citizens of Humanity, Cole Haan, Columbia, Dansko, Diane von Furstenberg, Dooney & Bourke, Elie Tahari, Ella Moss, Ellen Tracy, Express, Fossil, Free People, Frye, Gap, J.Crew, J Brand, Jimmy Choo, Joe's Jeans, Kate Spade, Lacoste, Lilly Pulitzer, Louis Vuitton, Longchamp, Lucky Brand, Lululemon, Madewell, Marc Jacobs, Marmot, Michael Kors, Minnetonka, Missoni, Nanette Lepore, Nike, Not Your Daughter's Jeans, Paige Premium, Patagonia, Polo, Puma, Ralph Lauren, 7 For All Mankind, Sperry Top-Sider, Splendid, Stella & Dot, Stella McCartney, Steve Madden, Stuart Weitzman, The Limited, The North Face, Theory, Tiffany & Co, TOMS, Top Shop, Tory Burch, Trina Turk, True Religion, UGG, Under Armour, Valentino, Velvet, Vince Camuto, Vineyard Vines, Wallace, We The Free, White House Black Market, Ya Los Angeles

Contact Us!

While what we really enjoy is seeing your smiling faces in person, you may also feel free to call or email us with any questions you may have regarding your account, balance, which items we are currently accepting or anything else you may be curious about! You can also find answers to your questions in the How to Consign/FAQs section of our website. We are available everyday from 9:30am to 5:00pm (Sundays 11:00am to 5:00pm).  We look forward to hearing from you!

The Latest from the Ladies at Pennywise


Now Accepting Winter Items

We are now accepting Winter clothing and accessories. This season our customers are asking for high-rise skinny jeans and high-rise wide leg jeans, chunky heel boots, oversized wool coats, and puffy vests. As always, our best selling brands are J.Crew, Vineyard Vines, Kate Spade, The North Face, Michael Kors and high-end designers. For more information on our consignment process please visit the How to Consign/FAQs section of our website. Keep in mind we do fill up quickly so it is always a good idea to call before coming to make sure we are accepting items at that time. We will be open for sales only on Monday, Columbus Day.


Lightweight Fall Begins Monday, July 13

We will begin accepting lightweight fall items on Monday, July 13. We will not be accepting heavier weight items or winter until later on in the season. For more info on our consignment process please check out the How to Consign/FAQs section of our site. 
Don't miss out on the huge summer sale currently happening! All shorts, capris and tank tops are 50% off plus purple tags throughout the store are 50% off. That means if it's a pair of shorts, capris or a tank top AND it's a purple tag it's on sale double! Shop the sale seven days a week. See you soon! 


No longer accepting Summer items except for...

We are no longer accepting Summer items this year except for Lilly Pulitzer, Vineyard Vines and high-end designer items (Kate Spade, Marc Jacobs, Tory Burch, etc). We will begin accepting lightweight Fall items in mid July. Please check back on our website or on our Facebook and Twitter pages for the exact date. In the meantime we are overstocked with great summer items from all of your favorite designers and brands. Check them out seven days a week!


Accepting Summer Items Until June 12

We will be accepting summer consignments until Friday, June 12. For more information on our consignment process please check out the "How to Consign/FAQs" section of this website. See you soon!


Now Accepting Spring and Summer!

We are now accepting Spring and Summer items for women and men! The 70s are back in style and this season our customers are looking for high-waisted flares and high-waisted shorts, bucket bags, and platformLilly Pulitzer Eyelet Dress sandals. Summer fit and flare dresses from brands like Lilly Pulitzer, J.Crew and Vineyard Vines are always in high demand as well. For a full list of the brands we accept and what we are currently looking for please refer to the lists on the right hand side of this page. As always, we only accept name brand and designer items and accessories, we do not accept lower end department store brands. Gap dress, Kate Spade tote and Adrienne Vittadini flatsWe accept consignments Monday through Friday from 9:30 to 4:00. For more information on our consignment policy please check out the How to Consign/FAQs section of our website. It is always a good idea to call before you come as we are sometimes too overstocked to accept more items that day. For daily updates keep up with us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. Happy Spring!