22 Greenmanville Ave.
Mystic, CT 06355

Sun. 11:00-5:00
Mon.-Sat. 9:30-5:00

Consignments Accepted and Checks Issued Mon-Fri 9:30-4:00
Excluding Holidays 



Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
/ ( mm / dd )



Now Accepting

*Boyfriend Fit shirts
*High Rise and Mid Rise skinny jeans
*High-Waisted flares
*Shirttail Dresses
*North Face, Patagonia and Marmot fleeces
*Designer Purses and Accessories
*Sterling and Gold Jewelry
*Alex & Ani Jewelry
*High-End Designer Items 

Not Accepting:
Winter Items
Formal Wear
Items more than two seasons old
Department store brands 

Acceptable Brands

AG Jeans, Alex & Ani, Alice + Olivia, Ann Taylor, Anthropologie, Athleta, Banana Republic, BCBG, Birkenstock, Boden, Born, Burberry, Catherine Malandrino, Christian Dior, Citizens of Humanity, Club Monaco, Coach, Cole Haan, Dansko, David Meister, Derek Lam, DKNY, DL1961, Dolce & Gabanna, Dooney & Bourke, DVF, Eileen Fisher, Elemente Clemente, Elie Tahari, Ella Moss, EMS, Express, Fossil, Free People, Frye, Gap, Garnet Hill, Gucci, Heidi Ost, Helly Hansen, J.Crew J Brand, Jack Rogers, James Perse, Jimmy Choo, Joe's Jeans, Joie, Kate Spade, Lacoste, Laundry, Lily Pulitzer, Loft, Longchamp, Louis Vuitton, Lululemon, Madewell, Marc Jacobs, Marmot, Maxmara, Michael Kors, Missoni, Nanette Lepore, Nike, New Balance, Nine West, NYDJ, Oscar de la Renta, Oska, Patagonia, Porto, Prada, Rachel Roy, Ralph Lauren, Ray-Ban, REI, Robert Rodriguez, Rockport, Royal Robbins, Sarah Carakasi, 7 For All Mankind, Shoshanna, Sorel, Sperry Top-Sider, Spirithouse, Stella & Dot, Steve Madden, Stuart Weitzman, Ted Baker, The Limited, The North Face, Theory, Three Islands, TOMS, Top Shop, Tory Burch, Trina Turk, True Religion, UGG, Valentino, Vera Wang, Via Spiga, Vince Camuto, Vineyard Vines, Wallace, We the Free, Ya Los Angeles, YSL

Contact Us!

While what we really enjoy is seeing your smiling faces in person, you may also feel free to call or email us with any questions you may have regarding your account, balance, which items we are currently accepting or anything else you may be curious about! You can also find answers to your questions in the How to Consign/FAQs section of our website. We are available everyday from 9:30am to 5:00pm (Sundays 11:00am to 5:00pm).  We look forward to hearing from you!

Steve Madden

Steve Madden is more than just the store pet, he plays an active role in the daily operations at Pennywise. He's always sharing his fashion advice and is getting better at looking up customer's balances (aka sprawling out across the Pennywise computers). Visit Steve's Corner to read his story and see pics of his friends!

The Latest from the Ladies at Pennywise


Now Accepting Spring Items!

The groundhog predicted an early spring and we want to make sure your wardrobe is ready! We are now accepting women's, junior's and men's spring items (not summer yet) for consignment. Our customers are already asking for mid rise and high rise skinnies, long-sleeve and short-sleeve tees, boyfriend fit shirts, TOMS and Sperrys, designer purses and sterling and gold jewelry. For a full list of the brands we accept please refer to the lower right hand side of this page. To view our consignment policy and rules visit the "How to Consign/FAQS" section of our site. 
Don't forget to keep up with us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram for daily updates and pics of new inventory. If you haven't already, you can sign up for email coupons and updates on our website. Happy Spring! 


Spring Consignments Begin Feb. 1

We will begin accepting Spring consignments on Monday, February 1. We will not yet be accepting Summer items at this time. We are looking for high-rise and mid-rise skinny jeans, straight leg and girlfriend fit jeans, shirttail dresses, boyfriend fit shirts, and designer purses and accessories. For a complete list of the brands we accept please refer to the list on the lower right hand side of this page. For a list of our consignment rules and policy visit the How to Consign/FAQs page. As always, keep up with us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram for news and new merchandise. Happy shopping!