Two Locations!

22 Greenmanville Ave.
Mystic, CT 06355


25 Cottrell St.
Mystic, CT 06355


We can now also be found on Pinterest and Instagram!

Now Accepting

Skinny, Straight Leg and Boyfriend Fit Jeans
Colorful and Patterned Skinnies
Designer Denim
Light-Washed Denim
 Skinny and Straight Leg Khakis
Fitted Capris
Top-Siders and Moccasins
TOMS Shoes
Popover Shirts
Boxy Crop Tops
Graphic Tops
Shift and Tunic Shirts
Boyfriend Shirts 
North Face and Patagonia Fleeces and Lightweight Jackets
Chambray Shirts
Fitted Trenches
Bomber Jackets
Boxy Top Jackets
Fitted Dresses
Tea Length Midi Skirts and Dresses
Pencil Skirts
Schoolboy Style Blazers
Stripes and Pastels
Cross-Body Bags
Bright Totes
Statement Jewelry
Jewelry- Sterling, Gold, Vintage
Designer Purses
Colorful Rain Boots
Vintage Clothing and Accessories

Not Accepting Department Store Brands, Winter Items, Knock-offs or Imitations, Items More Than Two Seasons Old


The Latest from the Ladies at Pennywise


Now Accepting Spring and Summer Items!

We are now accepting Spring and Summer Items at both Pennywise and Pennywise Downtown. This year our best sellers are colorful skinnies, chambray shirts and dresses, tea-length skirts, lighter denim (no flares), cross-body bags, statement jewelry and Sperrys and Toms shoes.TOMS and Sperrys at Pennywise For complete lists of items and brands we are currently accepting please refer to the list on the right hand side on the bottom of this page. We do not accept items more than two seasons old or from lower end department stores such as Kohls, JCPenney, etc. For more info on our specific rules please check out the How to Consign/FAQ section of our website. We accept all women's and men's clothing at Pennywise on Greenmanville Ave and all kid's clothing at Pennywise Downtown on Cottrell St Monday thru Friday from 9:30-4:00.
For those of you looking for great deals on designer items for Spring, we are stocked with everything from Gap to Lilly Pulitzer to Jimmy Choo! Keep up with us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter for daily pics and updates so you don't miss anything. Both locations are open seven days a week until 5:00. Happy shopping!



Huge Winter Clearance!

There's a huge Winter clearance going on now at both locations! All Coats and Sweaters are now 50% off and all Purple Tags throughout the stores are 25% off! That means coats from The North Face, Patagonia, J.Crew, Ralph Lauren and Burberry are all an additional 50% off our already low prices, even cashmere sweaters are half off! Hurry down to Pennywise on Greenmanville Ave. for women's and men's sales and Pennywise Downtown on Cottrell St. for women's and kid's sales, both locations are open seven days a week. 

We are currently accepting transitional items (no more winter items but not yet spring) such as skinny and straight leg jeans and pants, chambray shirts, pencil skirts, top-siders and hoodies. For a complete list please scroll down to the list on the right hand side of this page. As always, we only accept name brand and designer items (no department store brands) and items are accepted Monday thru Friday from 9:30-4:00 only.

Happy New Year! 


Thank You For Another Great Year!

As 2013 comes to a close we want to thank you all for another successful year for both of our stores. This year Pennywise celebrated 25 years at this location, something we could not have done without all of your support. Our second location, Pennywise Downtown, continues to grow adding a larger women's and vintage section along with children's and teen's clothing.
Many of you know the reason we have this business is to support our rescue animals. Between Donna and Lorell there are two cats, two dogs and three horses all living the good life. Without all of you we would not be able to rescue these animals in desperate need of homes and medical care. On behalf of our family both four-legged and two we thank you all and wish you a wonderful 2014!


No Longer Accepting Winter Items Except...

We are full to bursting with sweaters, coats and boots so we are no longer accepting winter items for this year with the exception of The North Face fleeces and jackets, Frye and Ugg boots and very high-end designer items. We begin accepting spring items in February but until then we will still accept selective transitional items such as skinny jeans and pants, hoodies, fitted long-sleeve shirts, top-siders, Toms and Minnetonkas. For a more complete list please refer to the right hand menu of this page. 


Accepting Winter Items until Nov. 22

We are accepting winter consignments at both stores until Friday, November 22. This year our biggest demands are for chunky cable knits, brightly colored, longer-length cardigans, Frye and Ugg boots, puffer vests and high-end designer purses. For a list of what we are currently looking for and the brands/designers we accept please refer to the lists on the right-hand columns of this page. As always, we accept all adult clothing at our Greenmanville Ave. location only and all children's clothing at our Cottrell St. location only.